the average guy thinks Game is a scam. But the salient point here isn't that tubby little Douchey McDoucherson has any idea what he's talking about, it is that if you have a conventional church-and-media-and-school-instilled idea of women and what they find attractive, even Douchey McDoucherson has a more advanced understanding of the opposite sex than you. That's why he's getting better results than you do, not because women are all secretly slavering for the Lesser Potbellied Love Machine.
Even a journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step. But don't make the mistake of believing that because Douchey McDoucherson is a few steps ahead of you, he has therefore reached the ultimate destination. When considering the advice of any PUA or theoretician of Game, the first thing you should keep in mind is if their objectives are in line with your own. A mismatch doesn't mean that they are necessarily wrong, but it does make you unlikely to reach your own goals by following their advice.